- Pitfalls to avoid when fighting antisemitism
- Not all calling out of oppressive behaviours have a net positive result.
- Antisemitism is part of a broader fight against racism.
- Litmus test for interventions
- Keep all Jews safe
- Not put any groups in danger/ more unsafe.
- Sullen solidarity
- No matter how awful someone is, no-one should face racism
- Solidarity needs to be unconditional to prevent people from harm.
- Principle 1 - ==People deserve to be safe even when they're wrong==.
- good Jews and bad Jews. Divisive. Deep historical roots.
- what tests do Jews have to pass before they are allowed to comment? What view is on IP
- non-Jewish groups using one type of Jews or one particular Jew to support their view
- Consensus antisemitism vs selective antisemitism
- Former is Nazis.
- Latter both loves and hates jews.
- This means that some jews deserve protecting, and some jews do not.
- Principle 2
- ==perpetrator vs victim==.
- Intersectionality easy to identify.
- But more difficult to identify when they are operating in opposite direction.
- Still have to protect them against antisemitism.
- Principle 3 - Jews vs other minorities
- Struggles not in competition
- Not zero-sum game
- teaching antisemitism is same as teaching isalmophobia,
- 5 ways this manifests:
- Comparing severity.
- Oppression olympics.
- Model minority.
- Shames other groups to be more like the Jews.
- No longer in need of support. Based in tropes
- Jewish exceptionalism. Jews are better/ worse than...
- "Jews should stay silent about antisemitism" as they have it better.
- Gut feeling. Holocaust over. Based in tropes.
- Existential threat as an individual and a race still exists.
- Heightened scrutiny.
- Antisemitism from minoritised groups are pounced on by other racists.
- What to do tomorrow: dismantling antisemitism in your institution & relationships
- Identify, interrupt and institutionalise
- Exercise agency about tropes and explain where they come from
- Intervention techniques are important. ==Need to deconstruct and unlearn antisemitism, not suppress it==
- Technique 1: "I used to think the same thing... "
- Technique 2: Tend to call it out. use 'cheerful and stupid' language trope.
- Come from a place of compassion.